Irishblogs.ie

Irishblogs.ie badge

Observing the Irish blogosphere since 2005

Ireland Is Telling Its Young People to Leave and Then Calling It a Lifestyle Choice

The figure that sits at the centre of this story is one the state does not particularly want to examine: in the year to April 2025, 35,000 Irish citizens emigrated from Ireland. In the same period, 31,500 returned. The Irish citizen population is, for the third consecutive year, a net exporter of its own people.

This is not a crisis in the acute sense. The numbers are not remotely approaching the famine emigration, or the 1950s emigration, or even the depths of the post-2008 emigration wave when the outflow of Irish citizens peaked at around 50,000 per year and every family in the country seemed to be putting someone on a plane to Sydney or Calgary. The government, when asked about the current figures, tends to observe that return migration is also strong, that the overall population continues to grow through net inward migration, and that Ireland's employment market remains among the most dynamic in Europe. None of this is false.

What it obscures is the specific character of who is leaving and why — and what that tells you about a state that has built one of the fastest-growing economies in the EU on the assumption that it does not need to make itself liveable for the people it produces.

Posted at: 27 May, 2026

The Australia Number

The most striking data point in the CSO's 2025 migration estimates is not the overall emigration figure. It is the Australia number. In the year to April 2025, an estimated 13,500 people left Ireland for Australia — a 27 per cent increase on 2024, and a 187 per cent increase on 2023. The highest level recorded since 2013, when Ireland was three years into the austerity programme that followed the bank guarantee and the IMF bailout.

This is worth dwelling on. The year 2013 was, by any honest accounting, close to the worst point of the most severe economic contraction in the history of the state since the 1950s. Unemployment was above 14 per cent. Wages were being cut across the public sector. Negative equity had trapped hundreds of thousands of households in homes they could neither sell nor afford. The conditions that produced that emigration wave were conditions of genuine economic emergency.

The conditions producing the current emigration wave to Australia are not those conditions. Unemployment in Ireland in 2025 was below 5 per cent. Employment in the technology and pharmaceutical sectors — which anchor much of the high-wage economy — remained strong. Irish GDP growth, whatever the legitimate methodological questions about how to measure it, continued to suggest an economy performing well above the European average.

What the current wave shares with the 2013 wave is not economic stagnation. It is housing. In 2013, people left because they had no work. In 2025, young workers describe Ireland as a place to build a CV rather than a future. The language has changed but the mechanism is the same: Ireland has become a place that educated, employable young people calculate they cannot build a life in at an acceptable cost. The calculation has simply shifted from wage income to housing access.

What the Cost of Living Actually Means

Dublin rents for a one-bedroom apartment averaged €2,200 a month in early 2026. The national median wage in Ireland, across all sectors, is roughly €44,000 per year — approximately €2,900 per month after tax for a single earner at that level. A one-bedroom apartment at Dublin's median rent consumes 75 per cent of that take-home pay before utilities, transport, food, childcare, or any form of savings.

This is not a marginal affordability problem. It is a structural impossibility for the majority of people earning at or below the median wage. The households that survive it are those where two full-time incomes can be combined, where parental help is available to bridge the deposit gap, or where the individual has deliberately selected into the top quintile of the income distribution. For everyone else, the arithmetic does not work and the response is either a very long commute from somewhere cheaper, prolonged cohabitation with parents, or emigration.

The electricity data adds texture to this picture. Eurostat figures for the second half of 2025 confirmed that Ireland now has the highest household electricity prices in the European Union — 40.42 cent per kilowatt-hour against an EU average of 28.96 cent. The average Irish household pays approximately €480 more per year for electricity than the EU average. That figure is not significant in isolation. It is significant as one component of a cumulative cost environment that sits at the top of the European range across multiple categories simultaneously: housing, childcare, transport, and utilities all in the highest European tier, against wages that are high in absolute terms but do not compensate for the premium fully.

Government indicators entering 2026 show a widening disconnect between earnings and housing access, particularly in urban centres. This is not a finding that requires sophisticated econometric analysis. It is visible in the choices that people in their twenties and thirties are making at scale.

Who Leaves and What They Take With Them

Around a third of emigrants in 2025 were aged 15 to 24. The majority of the rest were aged 25 to 44. This is, in other words, substantially a young and working-age emigration. The people leaving are not primarily people at the end of their working lives moving somewhere warmer. They are people at the beginning of their working lives making a calculation about where to build them.

The state has invested, over eighteen or twenty years of their lives, somewhere between €100,000 and €200,000 in the education of each of these individuals — in primary schools, secondary schools, in subsidised third-level places, in the medical card that covered their childhood healthcare, in the public infrastructure they used. When they leave at 25, having just completed a degree or a professional qualification, the return on that investment accrues to Australia or the United States or Canada. The Irish exchequer paid for the formation of the human capital. Someone else's economy benefits from its deployment.

This is not an argument against emigration as a personal choice. People have always moved, and movement is valuable — individually and often eventually for the country that people return to with different experience. The net return migration figure of 31,500 in 2025 includes many people who left in previous years and came back, and their return carries genuine value.

But the current situation is not balanced. The Irish who are leaving are predominantly at the beginning of careers, with full human capital and decades of productive working life ahead of them. The Irish who are returning are more distributed across the age profile — some returning at peak earning years, some retiring home. The exchange is not symmetrical, and the direction of the asymmetry is not in Ireland's favour.

The Government's Answer and Its Limitations

The standard government response to questions about emigration runs through employment statistics and net migration figures. Employment is high. Population is growing. Net migration is positive. More people are coming in than going out. These are the facts it chooses to present.

What this framing carefully avoids is any engagement with the specific question of Irish citizens — people the state formed and educated — choosing to leave a country with near-full employment because they cannot afford to live in it. The population growth that results from net positive migration is real but it is a different phenomenon from the departure of native Irish citizens. Replacing skilled Irish workers who leave with skilled workers from elsewhere is not the same as retaining them. It is a workable second-best. It is not a solution.

The housing policies announced through 2025 and into 2026 — the modular homes exemption expansion, the rural planning statement that is coming, the various schemes aimed at increasing supply — are all, in principle, movement in the right direction. The problem is pace. The planning system moves slowly. The supply of new housing responds slowly. The people making emigration decisions this year are not making them against the housing market of 2029 when some of these policies might have produced effects. They are making them against the housing market of right now.

There is a version of this story that ends well: the supply measures work, the cost pressures ease, a generation that went to Sydney in their twenties comes back in their thirties to the country they actually want to live in. There is evidence that this is at least partially true of previous waves — the 2013 cohort who went to Australia came back in significant numbers when the economy recovered and housing, relatively speaking, was affordable again.

The difference between then and now is that the housing crisis of the current period is structural in a way that the 2013 crisis was not. In 2013, the housing problem was a debt problem: too much was built, in the wrong places, at inflated prices, and the deleveraging that followed froze the market. The resolution was primarily time and debt restructuring. The current housing crisis is a supply problem: not enough is being built, in the right places, at accessible prices, to house the population that exists and continues to grow. The resolution requires sustained construction at a scale that Ireland has not consistently achieved, in locations that require infrastructure investment that has not been made, at a cost that requires subsidy that has not been fully committed.

What Is Actually Being Said

When 35,000 Irish citizens leave in a single year, at a time of near-full employment, headed primarily for countries with similar language and professional opportunity but where housing is more accessible — what is being communicated is not that Ireland is economically unsuccessful. It is that Ireland has built an economy whose success concentrates in forms that do not distribute to the people trying to start their adult lives in it.

The tech sector wages that anchor the high-income economy bid up the housing costs that price out the nurse, the teacher, the social worker, and the junior engineer. The international capital that flows through Ireland in the form of foreign direct investment does not build housing. The landlord class that has expanded as institutional investment entered the rental market extracts income from renters who are paying more of their wages for less security than any comparable European country provides.

None of this is a natural disaster. It is a series of policy choices, and policy choices can be changed. The planning reform coming in late 2026 is a policy choice. The tax treatment of landlords is a policy choice. The level of public investment in social housing is a policy choice. The cost structure of childcare — which this year consumes approximately 28 per cent of net household income for a two-child Dublin family — is a policy choice.

When 13,500 people leave for Australia in a year when Ireland has 5 per cent unemployment, they are not failing. They are responding rationally to the signal that the policy environment is sending them. The signal is: this place is not designed for you to stay in.

Until the policy environment changes that signal, the emigration figures will continue to tell you the same thing the people leaving already know.

Disclaimer
Opinions expressed are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of Irishblogs.ie.

Irishblogs.ie is committed to providing a platform for diverse perspectives and open dialogue. The content published in this post is the author’s own and does not represent the editorial stance or opinions of Irishblogs.ie, its team, or its affiliates. While we encourage robust discussion and the sharing of ideas, we may agree or disagree with the views presented here.

For questions or concerns about this content, please contact the author directly or reach out to us at [email protected]

Cookies Notice
We use cookies to collect anonymous data for analytics purposes, helping us improve our website and user experience. By continuing to use this site, you agree to our use of cookies.